Alphabetical List of Locations


Mythconception 1 : Moddey Dhoo & Snarleyow


Mythconception 2: The Vikings


Analysing....part 1

                  part 3

                  part 4

                  part 5


Dubious Cases


Related Creatures


Links & Reviews

Analysing the Hell out of the Beast

Part Two: Size and Eyes

Although the mythology says that Shuck is always enormous (often 'the size of a calf'), let's see if that is borne out by the stories.

Of the 82 legends collected here, only 29 (35.3%) even mention size at all, which is surprising. The descriptions range from the fairly normal 'large' or 'big', through 'huge' and 'enormous', to 'calf-sized', 'donkey-sized', and 'sometimes as big as a bullock.' With the encounters, 59.2% mention the size, with a similar kind of range.

Size Legends: Number of Instances Encounters: Number of Instances
Fairly 'normal' size 14 50
'Unnatural' size 15 56

The split is very nearly even, which somewhat blunts the statement in Janet and Colin Bord's 1987 book 'Modern Mysteries of Britain' that paracanines are "always large, bigger than the biggest dog and often described as calf-sized." 

Of those giving an 'unnatural' size, only 2 of the legends state that the dog is 'calf-sized', and only 13 of the encounters. Of those 13, only 3 have occurred since the 1940's - and that's probably because not many people nowadays have much of a notion of exactly how big a calf is! Being a townie myself (though on the edge of the countryside), and not having been anywhere near cows since I was a kid, I certainly have no idea! And what age of calf? Newly-born? Six months old? Just when does a calf stop being a calf and become a cow?

These questions might seem mundane, but an awful lot of the descriptions of size depend on the witness's perceptions. Without a definition of 'large', 'big' or 'huge' from the witness's point of view, such descriptions are relatively meaningless.

One witness described the dog they saw as "large, about 2 1/2 feet tall." Another said that their paracanine was "large, the size of a Great Dane." Two very different meanings of the term 'large.'

Great Danes, St. Bernards and Irish Wolfhounds regularly exceed 36" (91cm) in height at the shoulder, so it's quite possible that, barring any other paranormal characteristics, what a witness has seen is a perfectly normal dog. (The tallest dog ever recorded, a Great Dane, stood 44" (112cm) at the shoulder, so we can be fairly sure that any dog bigger than that is just a bit out of the ordinary!)

Now to the eyes. Those saucer-sized, fiery, glowing eyes, that strike fear into the witness's heart. I was startled to find that only 20 (24.4%) of the legends mention eyes at all. And only 32 (17.8%) of the encounters. Not very much upon which to build a substantial part of the mythology of Shuck.

The single Cyclopean eye only turns up once in the legends of East Anglia, and three times in actual encounters. Below is a broad breakdown (note that different descriptions may apply to the same eyes), followed by a more detailed breakdown of the precise eye description:

Eyes Legends: Number of instances Encounters: Number of Instances
Saucer-sized 7 2
Fiery/shining/glowing etc. 10 21
Red 3 9
Yellow 2 3
Orange   1
Green   2
Brown   1
* * *
Single, blazing 1  
Blazing saucers 2  
Blazing, fiery 2 2
Shining like fiery coals   1
Orange fireballs   1
Like bike lamps 1 1
Like lamps   2
Gleaming 1 1
Glowing 1 3
Luminous   1
Big, shining 1 2
Saucers, shining   1
Saucers 5 1
Single, yellow   1
Single, glowing   1
Yellow   1
Yellow with red centres 1  
Great, yellow 1  
Dead man's eyes 1  
Red 2 4
Single, red   1
Big, red 1 2
Huge, flaming red   1
Orange   1
Green   1
Shining bright green   1
Brown   1
Ferocious   1
Glaring   1
Terrible   1
Largish   1

In the encounters, the 2 examples of 'saucer eyes' come from the 1910's and 1970's. The eyes 'blazing', 'fiery' or 'like coals' are spread from the early 1800's to the late 20th century, while those 'shining', 'glowing' or 'like lamps' are confined to pre-1940, apart from four, in 1982, 1995, 1996 and the early 2000's.

Those described as 'gleaming',  'glaring' or 'yellow' could well be the result of light reflecting back from the dog's eyes in a perfectly normal manner.

                                                                                                                                                           PART THREE >>